The menu at Libertine feels carefully curated, balancing classic French technique with a confident, modern New York sensibility, and the cohesion across dishes is what stands out most. The experience naturally begins with Wine and a well-executed Martini, both of which set a refined tone without overshadowing the food. Starters like Bread with Butter and Chicken Liver Mousse, Anchovies, and Gougère establish a rich, savory foundation, while lighter options such as Caesar Salad and Brussels Sprouts provide welcome contrast. Raw preparations are clearly a strength here, with both Steak Tartare and Beef Tartare delivering clean, precise flavors that feel confidently restrained. Seafood dishes such as Scallop Seaweed and Scallop with Fennel highlight freshness and balance, avoiding unnecessary complexity. Moving into heartier plates, Gnocchi offers comforting depth, while Sausage and Mashed Potatoes leans fully into rustic indulgence. Duck appears repeatedly and thoughtfully across the menu, with Duck Two Ways showcasing versatility and Duck Breast standing as a more focused, elegant main. Traditional French elements like Jambon Persillé reinforce the restaurant’s bistro roots without feeling dated. Desserts continue the strong finish: Mousse Au Chocolat is rich and classic, Tarte Tatin delivers familiar caramelized warmth, and Rice Pudding Desert provides a softer, nostalgic close, while Baked Alaska adds a touch of theatrical flair. Taken as a whole, the menu feels intentional and well-edited, offering variety without excess and leaving a clear impression of a kitchen that values balance, technique, and consistency above trends.